Surprise: Dinosaurs Laid Blue Eggs!

Thursday, September 21, 2017

Surprise: Dinosaurs Laid Blue Eggs!

In a twist for paleontologists, a fossil nest found in China shows that coloured eggshells were not just for the birds.

Robins may be famous for their beautiful blue eggs, but ancient feathered dinosaurs beat them to the punch.

Looking at fossil eggshells from China, researchers have found evidence that an omnivorous, ostrich-like dinosaur laid clutches of blue-green eggs, potentially helping to camouflage them in open nests dug into the ground.

The discovery overturns a common assumption: “Everyone thought dinosaur eggs were white,” says study co-author Jasmina Wiemann at Yale University.

Many birds lay white, unpigmented eggs—as do all lizards, turtles, crocodiles, and the only known egg-laying mammals, the platypus and the echidna. For this reason, ornithologists had long assumed that coloured eggshells evolved solely in some groups of birds after nonavian dinosaurs had died out.

“Once the idea that coloured eggs evolved in birds and were a trait of modern birds had been suggested, no one thought about it again or dared to ask if dinosaur eggs had been coloured,” Wiemann says.

Fossil research has shown that birds and dinosaurs shared behaviours such as brooding and nest building. According to paleontologist and National Geographic grantee Jack Horner, it also stands to reason that dinosaurs had similar courting behaviors as today’s birds.

Now, a study by Wiemann and her colleagues in Germany and California pushes back the origins of coloured eggs at least as far as the Late Cretaceous.

As they report in the journal PeerJ, a species of oviraptor called Heyuannia huangi had eggs that were coloured deep blue-green. Commonly found in the fossil beds of eastern China, Heyuannia was a parrot-beaked, feathered species that walked on its hind legs and would have been about five feet long.

While many fossil dinosaur eggs are black or brown due to the fossilisation process, the eggs of Heyuannia have an unusual blueish tint to them. This made the scientists wonder if the eggs could harbor any of their original colour.

Using chemical analyses, they were able to detect traces of two pigments, biliverdin and protoporphyrin, commonly found in modern bird eggs. Millions of years ago, the eggs would likely have been a greener colour, Wiemann says, perhaps similar to eggs laid by Australia’s ground-nesting emus and cassowaries today, which blend in well with the surrounding vegetation.

“I was originally taught that all the weird colours you can get in fossils, like the blueish-green hue, may be due to mineral precipitation,” Wiemann says.

“We screened through lots of eggshells, and one day had a positive result for these oviraptor eggs. It was a huge surprise. I couldn’t believe it.”

Chemical analyses of the fossil eggs detected traces of the pigments biliverdin and protoporphyrin, commonly found in modern bird eggs. PHOTOGRAPH BY TZU-RUEI YANG, THE PALEOWONDERS MUSEUM OF FOSSILS AND MINERALS, TAIWAN.


The discovery highlights how much our thinking has changed about dinosaur preservation and how much more we can learn about the original animal, says David Varricchio, an expert on dinosaur reproduction at Montana State University who was not involved in the research.

The discovery of pigment traces “exemplifies the growing field and potential of molecular paleontology,” Varricchio says. “With new machines and new techniques, it’s very exciting what can potentially be found in fossils.”

Some paleontologists have argued that theropod dinosaurs, which included the ancestors of modern birds, had open nests with partially exposed clutches, Varricchio says. This new discovery helps confirm that idea, as pigmented shells today are only found in bird species that have exposed eggs.

Coloured eggs in birds is just one example in a whole series of traits formerly thought to be unique to birds—such as feathers and wishbones—that were in fact inherited from the dinosaurs, says Mark Norell, a palaeontologist at the American Museum of Natural History in New York City.

“Dinosaurs evolved coloured eggs before birds evolved—and the reason birds have coloured eggs is because they were present in their ancestors, the nonavian dinosaurs,” he says.

Wiemann is now looking for other examples of egg color among the carnivorous species closely related to birds that had open nests. She is also looking to see if any dinosaurs laid eggs with streaks or speckles on them.

“Lots of ground birds have patterned eggs with spots all over them,” says Norell. “It would be really neat if we could show that some of these dinosaur eggs were kind of camouflaged as well.”

Lead Image: A fossil nest found in China belonged to the oviraptor Heyuannia huangi, a parrot-beaked, feathered species that lived in the Late Cretaceous. PHOTOGRAPH BY TZU-RUEI YANG, THE PALEOWONDERS MUSEUM OF FOSSILS AND MINERALS, TAIWAN